Comments on: Breaking Dawn Backlash? http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/ Product Reviews, Book Reviews, Mom Reviews, and Giveaways Fri, 19 Mar 2010 23:30:53 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=abc hourly 1 By: Love http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/comment-page-1/#comment-25309 Love Wed, 15 Apr 2009 21:29:29 +0000 http://bookroomreviews.wordpress.com/?p=652#comment-25309 I believe Stephenie is an amazing auuthor and think that anyone who didn't like breaking dawn and returned it should suck it! Yeah it didn't have an explosive ending and could have ended in a better way get over it it's done and just a book. I don't think Renesmee's birth was pointless it had meaning to it Bella and Edward both finally got what they wanted. And a story without a fight and blood shed is the best , in my opinion. I think Meyer sets a good example for young teens out there too. It makes teens want to aspire to find someone who truly loves them and wait for marriage to have sex. I love this series and the way Meyer writes her stories are only meant for sheer in enjoyment NOT OVER ANALYISING! I believe Stephenie is an amazing auuthor and think that anyone who didn’t like breaking dawn and returned it should suck it! Yeah it didn’t have an explosive ending and could have ended in a better way get over it it’s done and just a book. I don’t think Renesmee’s birth was pointless it had meaning to it Bella and Edward both finally got what they wanted. And a story without a fight and blood shed is the best , in my opinion. I think Meyer sets a good example for young teens out there too. It makes teens want to aspire to find someone who truly loves them and wait for marriage to have sex. I love this series and the way Meyer writes her stories are only meant for sheer in enjoyment NOT OVER ANALYISING!

]]> By: Hikari http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/comment-page-1/#comment-22166 Hikari Thu, 02 Apr 2009 20:39:07 +0000 http://bookroomreviews.wordpress.com/?p=652#comment-22166 I came to this page curious because I found something, that told me about some sort of scandal about Breaking Dawn. I was interested to find the scandal. I personally found it inconceivable that anyone did not like the ending of this facsinated series. I am a 32 year old career woman with a nine to five and two kids. I watched the movie out of curiosity and I have always enjoyed vampire stories. The movie was cute. So I decided to purchase the book. I bought Twilight and quickly became engrossed. I am an avid reader usually reading between 5 and 12 books a week everything from Stephanie Laurens, J.K. Rowling, to James Patterson. Charles Dickens. Everything and anything. Koontz and King. I simply love to read. I know fluffy teen stories I have read them. I have even enjoyed them. I can not imagine anyone describing Ms. Meyers stories as fluffy. There is as much depth to the character of Edward as there is to Alex Cross. And to say that the birth of Rennesme was not appropriate and then using the f word on the same page is offensive to me. In two thousand pages the relationship between these two people took a natural progression. With unatural sircumstances. You can not exspect them to never have a real physical relationship. The fact that Stephanie put so much emphasis on Marrige is better than a teen show on tv right now on ABC family, where a young girl becomes pregnant from being irresponsible. Teenage girls can see that but not a married couple have a baby. Yes the birth is beyond reality. Ofcourse in case no one noticed It is a vampire and a human. And it does cover old myths I read about in my teens. They made a movie about it in the seventies Rosemary's Baby was loosely based off the same myth. So nothing new. I believe what bothers most people is that it was as far as they were concerned antclimactic. However. Stephanie is a character writer and fell in love with her characters as I did. She did not want to kill them and I did not want them to die. Life is so full of death why should our dreams have to be full of it too. I think the fact the the book ended with a diplomatic solution was something people should try to consider not scoff at. Too bad more people don't consider diplomacy and forethought or there would be less war in the world. I throughly enjoyed the stories and was very pleased at the ending. Thankyou for allowing me my opinion. I came to this page curious because I found something, that told me about some sort of scandal about Breaking Dawn.
I was interested to find the scandal. I personally found it inconceivable that anyone did not like the ending of this facsinated series. I am a 32 year old career woman with a nine to five and two kids. I watched the movie out of curiosity and I have always enjoyed vampire stories.
The movie was cute. So I decided to purchase the book. I bought Twilight and quickly became engrossed. I am an avid reader usually reading between 5 and 12 books a week everything from Stephanie Laurens, J.K. Rowling, to James Patterson. Charles Dickens. Everything and anything. Koontz and King. I simply love to read.
I know fluffy teen stories I have read them. I have even enjoyed them. I can not imagine anyone describing Ms. Meyers stories as fluffy.
There is as much depth to the character of Edward as there is to Alex Cross.
And to say that the birth of Rennesme was not appropriate and then using the f word on the same page is offensive to me.
In two thousand pages the relationship between these two people took a natural progression. With unatural sircumstances. You can not exspect them to never have a real physical relationship. The fact that Stephanie put so much emphasis on Marrige is better than a teen show on tv right now on ABC family, where a young girl becomes pregnant from being irresponsible. Teenage girls can see that but not a married couple have a baby.
Yes the birth is beyond reality. Ofcourse in case no one noticed It is a vampire and a human. And it does cover old myths I read about in my teens. They made a movie about it in the seventies Rosemary’s Baby was loosely based off the same myth. So nothing new. I believe what bothers most people is that it was as far as they were concerned antclimactic. However. Stephanie is a character writer and fell in love with her characters as I did. She did not want to kill them and I did not want them to die. Life is so full of death why should our dreams have to be full of it too.
I think the fact the the book ended with a diplomatic solution was something people should try to consider not scoff at. Too bad more people don’t consider diplomacy and forethought or there would be less war in the world.
I throughly enjoyed the stories and was very pleased at the ending.

Thankyou for allowing me my opinion.

]]> By: Abby http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/comment-page-1/#comment-1697 Abby Wed, 13 Aug 2008 12:15:14 +0000 http://bookroomreviews.wordpress.com/?p=652#comment-1697 I loved the book! It seems people are upset because Bella is no longer the insecure teenager. Both Bella and Edward have matured, the relationship was taken to the next level - it has intensified. If you want a battle - go read Harry Potter. I found the dealings with the Volturi to be more intense and intelligent than just a bloodshed. They were willing to do for each other. Edward and Bella's romance will last for eternity, with no regrets. As for books being returned - if you read it, you own it! Get a library card! I loved the book! It seems people are upset because Bella is no longer the insecure teenager. Both Bella and Edward have matured, the relationship was taken to the next level – it has intensified. If you want a battle – go read Harry Potter. I found the dealings with the Volturi to be more intense and intelligent than just a bloodshed. They were willing to do for each other. Edward and Bella’s romance will last for eternity, with no regrets. As for books being returned – if you read it, you own it! Get a library card!

]]> By: Scandal, Sex, and Vampires | Literary Escapism http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/comment-page-1/#comment-1696 Scandal, Sex, and Vampires | Literary Escapism Mon, 11 Aug 2008 21:48:12 +0000 http://bookroomreviews.wordpress.com/?p=652#comment-1696 [...] Book Room Reviews talks about the proported backlash. “Out of 1.3 million copies sold, Barnes and Noble has had FIFTEEN copies returned. Ooh such a backlash!” [...] [...] Book Room Reviews talks about the proported backlash. “Out of 1.3 million copies sold, Barnes and Noble has had FIFTEEN copies returned. Ooh such a backlash!” [...]

]]> By: Miao Ru http://www.bookroomreviews.com/2008/08/07/breaking-dawn-backlash/comment-page-1/#comment-1695 Miao Ru Mon, 11 Aug 2008 14:55:58 +0000 http://bookroomreviews.wordpress.com/?p=652#comment-1695 When I read Breaking Dawn, I enjoyed it. Bella is 18 and an adult. She can do whatever she wants. When I read Breaking Dawn, I enjoyed it. Bella is 18 and an adult. She can do whatever she wants.

]]>